Our Team

Holly Johnson (she/her/hers)

Pastor
Email Holly

Holly Johnson is a pastor in the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, but she wasn’t born that way. She grew up in the midwest (Minnesota, Illinois, and Nebraska) and “Pastor” was not in any part of any dream she had of what she would be when she grew up. Instead, her career dreams included: Singer in a band, teacher, nurse, and admissions director. In various ways, she has covered those things, except the nursing part.

In her adult life, she’s spent time on the West Coast as a youth director, a campus minister at Concordia College, a mission developer in Fargo-Moorhead, and as an administrator at Pacific Lutheran Theological Seminary in Berkeley, CA.

Holly found Spirit Garage during what she thought would be a break from church after years of youth ministry. She says:  “But before I quit, I had to go check out this church I had heard about called, ‘Spirit Garage' in Minneapolis. I went by myself. I hoped no one would talk to me. I walked in, and the guy who leads music was standing in the lobby. He offered me coffee and said, ‘Hey, they’re just getting started in there, so go ahead and get your coffee and sit anywhere you like.’ Then he went into the worship space (a theater) and welcomed everyone, saying, ‘We’re here to worship God. You can participate in whatever ways work for you. Sing if you want, dance if you want, share the meal if you want, but welcome.’ Then he explained that they have been doing a series on ‘experiencing God through the senses,’ and today was taste day. They sang Sarah McLachlan’s song ‘Ice Cream;’ I heard that song in a new way, I thought about communion in a new way, and I went back every week to see what would happen next. I never took that break from church.”

Holly likes good music, good poetry, good wine, good food, brunch, The Breakfast Club, and all things that blend sacred and secular.

Holly began at Spirit Garage in November 2017.

Andy Pokel (he/him/his)

Minister of Music + Community Connections
Email Andy

Andy Pokel (poke-ELL) grew up in Neenah, WI, and studied K-12 Vocal Music Education at St. Olaf College. After graduating, Andy toured with Missoula Children’s Theater for two years, then began his career in education. For a decade, Andy taught music, theater, and special education. More recently Andy has worked as a church musician at Lutheran Church of the Good Shepherd (Minneapolis, MN) and Woodlake Lutheran (Richfield, MN) and as a freelance writer/composer for Church Anew, the Convergence Music Project, the Reverb Collective, Sundays & Seasons, and faith+lead.

Andy is recent graduate of Luther Seminary, where he studied Christian Ministry and served as Musician in Residence. Andy is working towards ordination in the ELCA as a deacon. Andy loves the way that music connects us—to our own emotions, to one another, and to God. Composing, recording, performing, and leading music are central parts of Andy’s call to serve in the church. 

Andy’s musical influences include Sufjan Stevens, Bon Iver, Phoebe Bridgers, Conor Oberst, Iron and Wine, Adrianne Lenker, and The Beths, but he also used to play in a punk band in high school. These days there’s a lot of kids’ music in his frequently-played list.

Andy’s wife, Elise, is lead pastor at Transfiguration Lutheran Church, an RIC congregation in Bloomington, MN. They collaborate on church music under the name Foundry Hymnal, and their music can be found on most streaming platforms. They are proud parents of two mischievous, marvelous children.

Andy began at Spirit Garage in June 2024.